A A
RSS

John Brennan vs. a Sixteen-Year-Old

Posted by Medea -

Tue, Jan 8, 2013

Pakistan: No More Drones!

  • Sharebar

Medea Benjamin

In October 2011, 16-year-old Tariq Aziz attended a gathering in Islamabad where he was taught how to use a video camera so he could document the drones that were constantly circling over his Pakistani village, terrorizing and killing his family and neighbors. Two days later, when Aziz was driving with his 12-year-old cousin to a village near his home in Waziristan to pick up his aunt, his car was struck by a Hellfire missile. With the push of a button by a pilot at a US base thousands of miles away, both boys were instantly vaporized—only a few chunks of flesh remained.

Afterwards, the US government refused to acknowledge the boys’ deaths or explain why they were targeted. Why should they? This is a covert program where no one is held accountable for their actions.

The main architect of this drone policy that has killed hundreds, if not thousands, of innocents, including 176 children in Pakistan alone, is President Obama’s counterterrorism chief and his pick for the next director of the CIA: John Brennan.
On my recent trip to Pakistan, I met with people whose loved ones had been blown to bits by drone attacks, people who have been maimed for life, young victims with no hope for the future and aching for revenge. For all of them, there has been no apology, no compensation, not even an acknowledgement of their losses. Nothing.

That’s why when John Brennan spoke at the Woodrow Wilson International Center in Washington DC last April and described our policies as ethical, wise and in compliance with international law,  I felt compelled to stand up and speak out on behalf of Tariq Aziz and so many others. As they dragged me out of the room, my parting words were: “I love the rule of law and I love my country. You are making us less safe by killing so many innocent people. Shame on you, John Brennan.”

Rather than expressing remorse for any civilian deaths, John Brennan made the extraordinary statement in 2011 that during the preceding year, there hadn’t been a single collateral death “because of the exceptional proficiency, precision of the capabilities we’ve been able to develop.” Brennan later adjusted his statement somewhat, saying, “Fortunately, for more than a year, due to our discretion and precision, the U.S. government has not found credible evidence of collateral deaths resulting from U.S. counterterrorism operations outside of Afghanistan or Iraq.” We later learned why Brennan’s count was so low: the administration had come up with a semantic solution of simply counting all military-age males in a strike zone as combatants.

The UK-based Bureau of Investigative Journalism has documented over 350 drones strikes in Pakistan that have killed 2,600-3,400 people since 2004. Drone strikes in Yemen have been on the rise, with at least 42 strikes carried out in 2012, including one just hours after President Obama’s reelection. The first strike in 2013 took place just four days into the new year.

A May 29, 2011 New York Times exposé showed John Brennan as President Obama’s top advisor in formulating a “kill list” for drone strikes. The people Brennan recommends for the hit list are given no chance to surrender, and certainly no chance to be tried in a court of law. The kind of intelligence Brennan uses to put people on drone hit lists is the same kind of intelligence that put people in Guantanamo. Remember how the American public was assured that the prisoners locked up in Guantanamo were the “worst of the worst,” only to find out that hundreds were innocent people who had been sold to the US military by bounty hunters?

In addition to kill lists, Brennan pushed for the CIA to have the authority to kill with even greater ease using “signature strikes,” also known as “crowd killing,” which are strikes based solely on suspicious behavior.

When President Obama announced his nomination of John Brennan, he talked about Brennan’s integrity and commitment to the values that define us as Americans.  He said Brennan has worked to “embed our efforts in a strong legal framework” and that he “understands we are a nation of laws.”

A nation of laws? Really? Going around the world killing anyone we want, whenever we want, based on secret information? Just think of the precedent John Brennan is setting for a world of lawlessness and chaos, now that 76 countries have drones—mostly surveillance drones but many in the process of weaponizing them. Why shouldn’t China declare an ethnic Uighur activist living in New York City as an “enemy combatant” and send a missile into Manhattan, or Russia launch a drone attack against a Chechen living in London? Or why shouldn’t a relative of a drone victim retaliate against us here at home? It’s not so far-fetched. In 2011, 26-year-old Rezwan Ferdaus, a Massachusetts-based graduate with a degree in physics, was recently sentenced to 17 years in prison for plotting to attack the Pentagon and US Capitol with small drones filled with explosives.

In his search for a new CIA chief, Obama said he looked at who is going to do the best job in securing America. Yet the blowback from Brennan’s drone attacks is creating enemies far faster than we can kill them. Three out of four Pakistanis now see the US as their enemy—that’s about 133 million people, which certainly can’t be good for US security. When Pakistani Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar was asked the source of US enmity, she had a one word answer: drones.

In Yemen, escalating U.S. drones strikes are radicalizing the local population and stirring increasing sympathy for al-Qaeda-linked militants. Since the January 4, 2013 attack in Yemen, militants in the tribal areas have gained more recruits and supporters in their war against the Yemeni government and its key backer, the United States. According to Abduh Rahman Berman, executive director of a Yemeni National Organization for Defending Rights and Freedoms, the drone war is failing. “If the Americans kill 10, al-Qaeda will recruit 100,” he said.

Around the world, the drone program constructed by John Brennan has become a provocative symbol of American hubris, showing contempt for national sovereignty and innocent lives.

If Obama thinks John Brennan is a good choice to head the CIA and secure America, he should contemplate the tragic deaths of victims like 16-year-old Tariq Aziz, and think again.

Medea Benjamin, cofounder of www.codepink.org and www.globalexchange.org, is author of the book Drone Warfare: Killing by Remote Control.

Popularity: 2% [?]

Tags: , , , , ,

  • Anonymous

    This is a copy of an e-mail I sent to Medea, whom I met in Cuba during her “internship” in that communist nation and where I never heard her condemn Castro’s dictatorship:

    Medea,

    I watched your heated exchange yesterday on Fox News with Juan
    Williams( a center left journalist by the way). I must say I had two
    huge surprises:
    1- To hear of you again after so many years. I met
    you back in 1981 when Susan Fanshell visited Cuba in a group I guided as
    a Cubatur guide. Your husband or companion then was a Cuban gentleman
    by the name of Jose Luis.

    2- My second surprise, and certainly a much bigger one, was to hear you bitterly criticize your country’s drone policy.

    Let me be clear Medea, I harbor not one iota of trust for any
    politician regardless of what ideology or “political liturgy”as I put
    it, he or she claims to follow. Politics is dirtier than a Haitian
    kitchen on a Sunday morning, and I respect and honor your right to have
    whichever political views you choose to; however, having lived in Cuba
    and not being a vociferous anti Castro fighter and instead devoting all
    your strength to condemn your country’s policies appears to me as a
    blatant double standard, and it reminds me of Jane Fonda’s pictures
    seating in a North Vietnamese anti aircraft battery back in the sixties.
    For all I know the drone policy may be the worst move any US
    administration has made, but at least they’re hurting OTHER people and
    not their OWN people as the Castro brothers you seemed so firmly to
    agree with have done for ever fifty years. You lived four years in Cuba
    according to Wikipedia, even though I have the feeling your Cuban
    “internship” lasted much longer than that. In the Code Pink website I
    saw no mention of your brush with the “dictatorship of the proletariat”,
    the one party rule, democratic centralism and all that jazz. Moreover,
    your rhetoric in the Factor last night was a 100% match with Linea y A’s
    talking points. I don’t elaborate on what Linea y A means in Cuban
    jargon since I’m sure you perfectly know what I’m talking about.

    As the aware American you pretend to be it is your duty to condemn and
    denounce all evil, wherever it comes from and enlighten your country’s
    public opinion. I have no beef if you think droning our enemies does
    more harms than good; the trouble is that I haven’t heard your
    condemnation of Chavez, Evo Morales, Correa, and of course your former
    hosts the good old Castro brothers. It’s a shame Medea. You probably
    have gone so much to the left that you have left America

    Andres Alburquerque.
    NOTE: This message will posted on my blog and my FB page

  • Anonymous

    Medea, I tried to post a copy of the e-mail I sent you but this system won;t allow me to do that; your talking points seem taken out of the Cuban Intelligence doctrine, c’mom

  • Anonymous

    Medea,

    I watched your heated exchange yesterday on Fox News with Juan
    Williams( a center left journalist by the way). I must say I had two
    huge surprises:
    1- To hear of you again after so many years. I met
    you back in 1981 when Susan Fanshell visited Cuba in a group I guided as
    a Cubatur guide. Your husband or companion then was a Cuban gentleman
    by the name of Jose Luis.

    2- My second surprise, and certainly a much bigger one, was to hear you bitterly criticize your country’s drone policy.

    Let me be clear Medea, I harbor not one iota of trust for any
    politician regardless of what ideology or “political liturgy”as I put
    it, he or she claims to follow. Politics is dirtier than a Haitian
    kitchen on a Sunday morning, and I respect and honor your right to have
    whichever political views you choose to; however, having lived in Cuba
    and not being a vociferous anti Castro fighter and instead devoting all
    your strength to condemn your country’s policies appears to me as a
    blatant double standard, and it reminds me of Jane Fonda’s pictures
    seating in a North Vietnamese anti aircraft battery back in the sixties.
    For all I know the drone policy may be the worst move any US
    administration has made, but at least they’re hurting OTHER people and
    not their OWN people as the Castro brothers you seemed so firmly to
    agree with have done for ever fifty years. You lived four years in Cuba
    according to Wikipedia, even though I have the feeling your Cuban
    “internship” lasted much longer than that. In the Code Pink website I
    saw no mention of your brush with the “dictatorship of the proletariat”,
    the one party rule, democratic centralism and all that jazz. Moreover,
    your rhetoric in the Factor last night was a 100% match with Linea y A’s
    talking points. I don’t elaborate on what Linea y A means in Cuban
    jargon since I’m sure you perfectly know what I’m talking about.

    As the aware American you pretend to be it is your duty to condemn and
    denounce all evil, wherever it comes from and enlighten your country’s
    public opinion. I have no beef if you think droning our enemies does
    more harms than good; the trouble is that I haven’t heard your
    condemnation of Chavez, Evo Morales, Correa, and of course your former
    hosts the good old Castro brothers. It’s a shame Medea. You probably
    have gone so much to the left that you have left America

    Andres Alburquerque.
    NOTE: This message will posted on my blog and my FB page

Latest Flickr photos
IMG_0300Pink marching BaltimoreMargaret Flowers on Oct 6 actionIMG_3471Medea Making new friendsDSC01117IMG_2327.JPGIMG_2337.JPGCodePink Vagina Monologues 937

Lifestream